Fuel Quality Differences


Click image for a larger view

When considering fuel quality, we’ve always thought first about water, rust, and other impurities in the fuel. Knowing we intended to travel the world and expecting poor quality fuel in the many less-developed countries we would visit, we left Seattle with 48 primary filters on board. What we have learned is that fuel quality is mission-critical in  less-developed countries and, generally, fuel quality has been remarkably good everywhere we’ve been.

In the 10,063 hours we have traveled with Dirona, we have never seen material water in the fuel. We have seen lots of rust and even a fairly large cockroach that came in with a fuel load, but nothing difficult to filter out. All fuel that gets to our Deere 6068AFM75 main engine has to pass through at least four levels of filtration and most fuel burned has passed through three of those filters many times. We’ve had no issues with fuel quality.


Click image for a larger view
Cockroach caught in fuel filter

In fact, the only time we have a truly poor fuel buying experience was on our previous boat in Northern British Columbia, Canada where we spent more than $5/gal to buy a load of fuel that included several gallons of water, also at $5/gal. It’s nasty seeing all that water in in the fuel system but even in this extreme situation, the filters pulled it out, the engines ran fine, and there were no follow-on issues.

We’ve noticed more recently, however, that there is more to fuel quality than avoiding debris and water in the fuel. The first is oil cleanliness. Our Deere has always produced black oil within minutes of an oil change. It’s not a big deal and it doesn’t indicate an engine problem, but on our engine, the oil just blackens the oil right away.

A weird thing happened over the year we spent in the UK and Ireland in 2017/2018. When we changed the oil, it didn’t blacken for more than 100 hours. Very few things on a diesel engine get better with wear so we were scratching our head as to why an engine with 9,000 hours would suddenly stop blackening the oil.

Another factor magically improved over that year. The dry exhaust has always produced some minor sooting on the boat deck under certain conditions. It doesn’t happen always but there is often minor sooting which, if it doesn’t get cleaned up quickly, even a few bits of soot end up ground in or streaked.  It’s ugly but it’s not that common nor that hard to clean. It’s made us slightly more interested in wet exhaust designs but, other than that, it’s not really been an issue. Many owners are careful to run hard before stopping the boat and to cover the exhaust stack so that water doesn’t run won the pipes. We’re told if you do this, you can virtually eliminate the problem.

On the sooting, another “magic” clean-up happened. Over the last six months in the UK and Ireland, we don’t recall cleaning any marks off the deck or the crane. It’s nice to see, but it seems weird that a 9,000 hour engine would end up improving.

It appears these improvements are due to fuel quality. Most of Dirona’s running hours have been on high sulfur content fuel. As we travel the world, we are often getting 500 PPM to even 1000 PPM. This is within the Deere specification and, for most of these locations, the choice is to take that fuel now or wait at the dock for few years for environmental regulations bring improvements. There are times when you have little choice on a fuel purchases.


Click image for a larger view

Click image for a larger view
John Deere Fuel and Oil Quality Specifications

Before travelling to Norway, we’d burned through 3 tanks of 10 ppm sulfur fuel purchased in Kinsale, Loch Maddy, and Dublin Ireland where Irish fuel standards require that fuel for non-road mobile machinery contain no more than 10 ppm sulfer. It didn’t make much difference at first but, over the six months, the oil stayed clean after a change and there were no soot marks on the deck.

Three months ago we took on a load of fuel in Tromso, Norway way up above the Arctic Circle and we are now back to 500 ppm sulfur fuel. We’ve seen some sooting return and the oil is again black. Our fuel injectors needed replacement at 9,000 hours which we think is respectably good. We suspect that if we’d spent the 9,000 hours on 10 ppm diesel, its possible we would still be running the original injectors.

Fuel quality is not just about avoiding water, rust, and other impurities. Higher sulfur content can increase wear, require more frequent oil changes, blacken the oil, and contribute to sooting.


Click image for a larger view
Taking on 10ppm diesel in Loch Swilly, Ireland

 


If your comment doesn't show up right away, send us email and we'll dredge it out of the spam filter.


7 comments on “Fuel Quality Differences
  1. David Cretney says:

    What about Cetane rating in the diesel fuel? Since you are in the European realm I thought the Cetane rating was several points higher than typical in North America. This might also contribute to better fuel efficiency and a cleaner burn

    • Yes, Cetane numbers of the fuels we have been using around the world certainly are different. I don’t have the Cetane numbers of the fuels I’ve been using so I don’t have a good comparative history on that dimension. I have noticed over the last previous year that the generator was able to operate at what was used to be full output with higher RPM suggesting that it was capable of taking more load. More recently it’s returned to normal now that we are running on Marine Gas Oil here in Norway. It’ll be interesting to see what happens when we end up using EN 590 diesel with a Cetane number of 51 and a sulfur content of less than 10 ppm. The higher Cetane number might make a difference — I’ll look for that as a possibility.

  2. Gary Gordon says:

    Fueling in the old days. Back in the mid 80’s we leave Los Angeles and fuel in San Diego then head for Cabo San Lucas Baja California. About half way refuel in Magdellana Bay. Med Moor to the pier, crane our tender and go to the pier. they would give us the fuel hose and we would take it to the boat. We had a large funnel and lined it with two layers of cheese cloth. This materially lengthened the time it took to fuel but you would not believe the “sludge and bugs” we prevented from going into our tanks. Fuel quality today appears to be much better.

    • Yes, I’ve seen the Baja filter approach but when taking on 1,000 gallons and sometimes as much as 2,000 gallons, it takes an hour and a half with excellent pump flow. This can rapidly become a big portion of a day if the flow rates is low. So, our approach is 4 layers of media filters. No fuel can reach the main engine without passing through each of: 1) 25 micron RACOR FBO-10 (popular in aviation, heavy equipment, and fuel distribution), 2) 2 micron RACOR 900, 3) 10 micron John Deere, and 4) 2 micron John Deere. All fuel will go through each of these 4 at least once and the vast majority of the fuel will pass through the last 3 of these many times. It’s pretty clean when it gets to the Deere but, you are right, it’s absolutely astounding what comes on board with the fuel.

  3. Trond Saetre says:

    Seems like the Deere engine responds better to the low sulfur fuel than my Volvo engine. I exclusively use low sulfur fuel (EN590 standard), and the oil doesn’t take long to turn black.

    This spring I installed a centrifuge fuel purifier in-line between the diesel tank and the single Racor pre-filter in my boat as an extra safety barrier. The centrifuge has so far removed all the (minor) contaminants I have experienced, and deliver clean fuel to the filter. Helped a lot on one occation when I got about half a liter of water and some muddy contaminants at one marina during a refueling. The filter remained clean, and the centrifuge took it all.
    Paid about 800USD including shipping from LandauUK to Norway.
    https://www.landauuk.com/products/latest-products/diesel-bug-fuel-purifier/

  4. Chris says:

    Ireland has become an excellent example of quality in most things in recent years. When we lived there in the 90’s, quality was far more relaxed.
    Following the Celtic Tiger and world financial crash, Ireland has led the way in environmental and sustainability issues. High quality fuel is just one example of those changes, if Ireland can do it, why can’t everybody else?

    Loving the journey and isn’t Norway just beautiful!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.