Seven Weeks at Gigha


Click for larger image

When we departed Amsterdam in February of this year, our plans were to spend the spring in Antwerp and the Atlantic coast of France and Spain, and the rest of the year in the Mediterranean. Since grocery shopping can be a hassle, we’d stocked up the boat planning not to need anything except produce and bakery products until we reached Genoa, Italy in July. So when our plans did change and we decided instead to head north to Scotland, we were able to provision the boat for a multi-week lockdown with only two grocery trips, one in Ramsgate, UK and the second in Portland, UK. We stocked up on more produce than we normally would, bought extra meat, and also purchased ingredients for baking bread and breakfasts.

Although our anchorage at the Isle of Gigha is a far different place than we expected when we left Amsterdam, we’ve been enjoying our time here. Our provisions have lasted well, we are enjoying our meals on board, the scenery is beautiful and we have good Internet connectivity. Life feels pretty normal on Dirona, except for the fact we’ve not been ashore for over seven weeks.

Earlier this week Boris Johnson addressed the nation on the UK lockdown plans going forward. Although the UK is slightly easing its restrictions, Scotland remains in lockdown. We were hoping the situation would have improved a bit by now so that we could reprovision outside a full lockdown, but it looks like that won’t happen until the end of May. Although it’s been eight weeks since we last provisioned in Portland on March 20th, we’re still in good shape on most supplies. We’re fine for now, but in a couple of weeks we’ll start running out of things, beginning with produce. It’s getting close to the time that we need to provision.

Below are highlights from May 1st through 11th, 2020. Click any image for a larger view, or click the position to view the location on a map. And a live map of our current route and most recent log entries always is available at mvdirona.com/maps.

5/1/2020
Click for larger image
Failed Ammeter
Ten years must be close to the lifetime of our power meters. All nine ran well for ten years but we just had the second failure in two months. On both of these failures, the display shows partial LED number segments and smells bad. Generally, with electrical gear, a bad smell is sign that there was excess heat that could possibly still be a problem. Having seen these gauges fail with overheated electronics, we immediately disconnect them when there’s any symptom of fault.
Click for larger image
Gigha
As the weather models indicated, conditions are wonderfully calm at the Isle of Gigha this morning, while the barometer begins a slow rise.
Click for larger image
Vinaigrette
The lettuce is lasting well, but we’re out of salad dressing. We have been making this delicious and easy-to-prepare French Vinaigrette since we were in Fiji in 2013. We were invited to dinner on the boat of two French brothers and offered to bring a salad. To go with it, we made our first-ever batch of homemade dressing using Felicity Cloake’s perfect vinaigrette recipe.

It’s a good thing we found a quality recipe—one of the brothers turned out to be a chef and the other owned a winery. When said they were “very surprised” about the dressing, we thought we’d messed it up somehow. But they went on to say it was delicious and asked if we’d made it with Dijon. Of course—who would dream of making French Vinaigrette without Dijon? :)

Click for larger image
Sunset
Golden sunset after a calm day at Gigha.
5/2/2020
Click for larger image
Laundry Day
It’s laundry day on Dirona—we usually do it every couple of weeks when we’re away from civilization. Scotland is in a fairly strict lockdown, where marinas and fuel docks are closed for recreational boating and non-locals. We’re lucky that Dirona is so self-sufficient, and that hasn’t been the slightest inconvenience for us. We’ve got a couple of months worth of food, more than a half-year’s worth of fuel, can do laundry on board, and can make water as we need it.
Click for larger image
Equalizing
Our operating conditions for the past five weeks have been quite unusual. We’ve been at anchor for the entire period, and haven’t been moving the boat. This has never happened before for this long a period. Normally the batteries will be fully charged frequently, either by moving the boat or being plugged into shorepower. When charging with the generator, we turn start charging at 55% charge and stop at 85%. It’s far better to fully charge lead acid batteries, but doing this daily is inefficient. They can be charged to 85% in around 2 hours but fully charging the batteries takes closer to 5 hours. Certainly, this can be done, but it’s a long time with the generator at very low load and it would mean the generator is running half the time. A recommended compromise is to fully charge weekly, or at most every two weeks.

Short cycling degrades battery capacity. Most, but not all, of the capacity lost by short cycling can be restored with equalization (also called conditioning), a controlled overcharge that de-sulphates the battery plates. We’ve been watching the battery capacity degrade surprisingly rapidly over the past few weeks— it is down by 34% over the last five weeks. We should have fully charged far earlier than this, but we thought it would be an interesting experiment to see how fast and how far the battery capacity degraded and how much would be restored by equalization. Today is laundry day, so we decided to take that opportunity to fully charge and then equalize the batteries and see how much battery capacity is lost in 120 consecutive short cycles and how much is restored in equalization.

Pictured is a the MasterAdjust software used to control our two Mastervolt chargers. The battery manufacturer, Lifeline, recommends temperature-corrected equalization (conditioning), and at our current battery temperatures, we’ll need 31.0V. To achieve that, we have increased the absorption and float voltage levels to 30.9 volts.

Click for larger image
DC-DC Converter
With the voltage higher than usual while we are equalizing the batteries, we got a warning that our 12-volt battery system was losing charge. It appears our 24-12V DC-DC Converter stopped charging the 12V battery. Its fairly common for electrical equipment to have sufficiently tight bounds on input voltage that period battery equalization might put them out of range. For example, our converter shuts off anytime the voltage is at 31 or above. Its best that any 24V equipment that’s not needed immediately be shut off during equalization. Well-designed gear should be absolutely fine, but you really don’t want to find out if your equipment is well-designed.
Click for larger image
Charging 12-Volt Battery
During equalization, our 12-volt battery for the navigation system isn’t being charged by the 24v-to-12v converter, so we charged it externally. We only need to do this if the voltage is sufficiently high to cause the converter to shut down, and the load on the 12-volt system is sufficiently high to require charging.
Click for larger image
Long Gen Run
The Gen Amps graph (second from top at the right) shows generator output over the past 24 hours. Visible are the 8-hour equalization run and two more normal generator runs to the left (click image for a larger view).
5/3/2020
Click for larger image
Sunrise
Sunrise over the Kintyre peninsula viewed from our anchorage at the Isle of Gigha.
Click for larger image
Post-Equalization
The long-term battery short-cycle test provided some really interesting results. Over 122 short cycles, our batteries lost 34% of capacity, which is far higher than we would have guessed. The equalization appears to have restored very close to all of that capacity. Our average time on battery for the past two days is identical to that of our first week at Gigha.

That shows us two things: 1) 122 consecutive short cycles will lead to rapid battery capacity reduction and 2) after equalization, the effective degradation of those 122 cycles (roughly 12% of the manufacturer’s nominal cycle lifetime) is fully nearly zero.

This is pretty surprising, and demonstrates that the negative impact of consecutive short cycles is remarkably small. Its also pretty interesting that consuming 12% of the manufacturer’s predicted lifetime of cycles shows almost no degradation at all. Closely related to this experiment, we will soon post a blog analyzing battery capacity over the lifetime of the bank.

Click for larger image
Sea Fog
Sea fog this morning at the Isle of Gigha.
5/5/2020
Click for larger image
Dawn
Spectacular pink dawn looking toward the Kintyre peninsula from our anchorage at the Isle of Gigha.
Click for larger image
Moonset
A bright near-full moon setting over the Isle of Gigha. The full moon in two days’ time is called the Flower Moon in the Northern Hemisphere because so many wildflowers bloom in the month of May.
Click for larger image
Glow Plugs
The generator continues to run well at 6,603 hours but currently has three minor issues that will eventually need some attention. The first is that the water seal on the sea water pump has started to seep slightly, so dried white dust is collecting underneath it. The issue is fairly minor, so we’ll leave it in service, but that pump will need to be replaced. Probably not that soon but its time is coming. The second issue is the rear main oil seal has started to leak a bit of oil. These problems usually take years to become anything more than nuisance leaks and some never get worse. However, we’re not so lucky on this one. In a month it’s gone from a barely noticeable oil mist from the generator cooling section to now spreading oil drops around the generator enclosure. It’s still not enough to actually drip but it seems to be worsening quickly. This one is really bad news since changing the rear main oil seal is a very big job requiring separating the generator section from the diesel engine to access the seal. The final issue is more minor. The engine takes a 3 to 4 seconds to start when it used to be 1 or 2 seconds faster. The last time this happened we found the fuel lift pump was loose and leaking air at the diaphragm.

The latest slower-than-normal to start issue is again very likely a fuel issue but, just to rule out the obvious stuff, James is checking the air filter and the glow plugs. Here he is testing the glow plugs by reading the current draw of the plugs. This circuit normally draws 16A or about 5.3A per glow plug. This quick test confirms that they are working normally so we’ll have to chase down the fuel issue since it seems to be slowly getting worse and a healthy engine should start in a couple of seconds.

Click for larger image
Spitfire
Whenever James is working the the engine room, Spitfire soon follows him in. He’ll sit on the engine room tray and call for attention whenever James walks past.
Click for larger image
Loaf
Another tasty loaf from our bread machine.
Click for larger image
Gigha
A wonderfully calm evening looking forward, aft, to starboard and to port (clockwise from upper left) around our anchorage at the Isle of Gigha.
Click for larger image
Dusk
Spitfire enjoying the last of the sun’s rays shortly before sunset at the Isle of Gigha.
5/6/2020
Click for larger image
More Bread
Yesterday’s loaf was consumed by breakfast this morning, so we’re making another.
5/7/2020
Click for larger image
Media Filter
We have a media filter in front of our water maker prefilter. The media filter is essentially a small sand filter very siimilar to that used on swimming pools. It’s super effective. In plankton rich waters, water maker prefilters can need to be replaced or cleaned weekly and sometimes as often as daily. With the media filter, we only change the prefilter annually when we change the carbon flush filter. The media filter has pressure guages showing when it needs to be cleaned, but we find it can go a very long time without building much back-pressure, so we just schedule the media filter for back-flushing monthly.

Cleaning the filter is quick and easy process. We reverse the valves, then run the booster pump, which runs seawater through the filter in the opposite direction, cleaning it. Here you can see the brown flush water coming out at the start of the flush cycle. We run the booster pump until the outflow water is clear, then shut it down and restore the valves to the forward flow.

Click for larger image
Celery
Making shrimp-salad pita pockets for lunch with the last of the celery bought in Portland seven weeks ago. Our produce has really lasted well with the green bag and paper towel treatment.
5/9/2020
Click for larger image
Sunrise
We’re enjoying some fabulous sunrises here at the Isle of Gigha.
Click for larger image
Boat Wash
James power-washing the boat while Jennifer follows behind with a bucket of soapy water washing and rinsing.
5/11/2020
Click for larger image
PM Address
Watching Boris Johnson address the nation on the UK lockdown plans going forward. Although the UK is slightly easing its restrictions, Scotland remains in lockdown.
Show locations on map Click the travel log icon on the left to see these locations on a map, with the complete log of our cruise.

On the map page, clicking on a camera or text icon will display a picture and/or log entry for that location, and clicking on the smaller icons along the route will display latitude, longitude and other navigation data for that location. And a live map of our current route and most recent log entries always is available at mvdirona.com/maps.

 
 


If your comment doesn't show up right away, send us email and we'll dredge it out of the spam filter.


5 comments on “Seven Weeks at Gigha
  1. Ed van Zadelhoff says:

    Hi James,

    On the generator starting issue you could try to put a one way valve in the fuel support line to see if that helps to indicate if the fuel is running back to the fuel tank.

  2. Jim S. says:

    Hi James,
    I know you have probably covered this elsewhere, and it will vary with load, but how long do you plan on being on battery alone in a given day? I assume the major driver is whether you are using AC or not. Are you able to go the night with the gen off?

    Stay safe!

    • We’re pretty serious power hogs so the boat will only run on batteries for about 68% to 75% of each day. It won’t go all the way through the night without requiring a generator run. We just let autostart start it when needed and stop it when 85% charged so it’s fairly unpredictable when it’ll run.

  3. Wyatt says:

    When you do eventually replace the batteries, will you switch to AGMs? I know the price/performance of wet cells is great and the maintenance is easy to perform, but it seems like eliminating some maintenance would be worth the additional cost. Are there disadvantages to AGMs beyond the cost?

    Have your good samaritans been by again recently to offer you supplies? It doesn’t sound like the situation is dire yet, but it would be good to know you still have some locals looking out for you.

    It’s good to hear you’re all ok.

    • I work with flooded Lead Acid a lot at work and used the wrong term when I referred to our bank as flooded. They are AGMs. 10 or 15 years ago, I preferred flooded due to better price point but the last purchase of Lifeline AGMs was pretty reasonably priced. I like them and wouldn’t go back. Eventually we’ll move to to Li-Ion but are held back by pricing, differences in form factors and wiring, and the required charging system parameter changes that would be required. It’ll be a big project when we do it.

      The islanders that work the nearby fish farm come out to check on us weekly. Really nice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.