On Board the CS Responder

Click image for a larger view

In this 21st edition of the Dirona Technology Series, we get an opportunity to explore the CS Responder, a trans-ocean cable-laying ship operated by TE SubCom.

TE Connectivity is $13.3B global technology company that specializes in communication cable, connectors, sensors, and electronic components. Their subsidiary TE SubCom manufactures, lays and maintains undersea cable. TE SubCom has a base in Baltimore and invited us to tour the facility and one of their cable-laying shipsThe visit included an overview of their cable-laying business and solutions, demonstrations on how undersea cables are made, and best of all, a tour of the CS Responder.

In the first picture below our guide on the tour, Jim Herron, is on the left and our host David Robles on the right. Jim started the day with an overview of the TE SubCom cable-laying business and the many challenges faced in the process, ranging from permitting to adverse weather to the job of actually laying the cable itself. A sister ship to the CS Responder, the Tyco Resolute (now CS Resolute) was featured on Discovery Channel Canada’s Mighty Ships documentary series. This episode, although somewhat dramatized, shows many of the challenges that cable-layers face and how they are managed. The Smithsonian Channel airs the series in the US. A trailer is on the Smithsonian Channel web site and the full episode is available on Amazon Video.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

Our first stop was the shore-based splicing training school. Brian Isenstadt showed us how splicers are trained to reliably connect tiny fiber optic links where the links are low-loss and sealed from water well enough to last 20+ years. The second photo below shows the stainless steel cartridge that maintains the mechanical strength of the cable and provides space for the up to eight individually-spliced tiny fiber-optic pairs.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

The first picture below shows the instrument that first aligns the optics and then fuses them together into a single unbroken fiber optic path. The screen in the second picture shows the two fiber ends being brought together into alignment to ensure a low signal-loss connection.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

The stainless steel splice cartridge is next permanently encased in a waterproof thermally-injected sealant. In the second picture below, the sealing material is inspected carefully for impurities, bubbles, or other flaws using X-ray.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

Repeaters are one of the biggest challenges to undersea cable longevity. High quality optical signals will only propagate for 60 to 80 km within high signal-to-noise standards. So, to cross an entire ocean, repeaters have to be used to boost the signal strength. These repeaters have to be able to operate reliably for 20+ years at depths beyond 3 miles. And they have to be strong enough to make it highly unlikely the cable will be torn apart at the repeater by weather, fishing activity, or other disturbances.

These repeaters are electrically powered with direct current (DC) and the power distribution system used is super interesting.  Each repeater is in series like an old-fashioned Christmas tree light string. This allows only a single conductor to be used to power all repeaters, greatly decreasing the cost of the cable. The downside of single-conductor DC powering is that shore side Power Feed Equipment (PFE) has to provide sufficient voltage to drive the potentially multi-thousand mile cable and all the cable repeaters along the ocean floor. To achieve the needed levels of redundancy, the PFE on one cable end supplies positive voltage and the PFE on the other ends supplies a roughly equal negative voltage. The combined difference of potential or voltage could be as high as 10,000 volts, although each repeater only sees a tiny portion of that difference of potential since they are all wired in series.

The two most common undersea cable failure modes are 1) PFE failure and 2) undersea cable power shunts to ground. Both failures have similar recovery mechanisms. If a PFE fails, the PFE on the other end doubles its voltage level to maintain the same difference of potential at each repeater allowing the cable to continue to operate without interruption until the PFE can be repaired. In the second fault mode, there is an insulation failure in the cable perhaps caused by fishing activity or weather action. This will allow the voltage at the insulator failure to drop to the ground plane neutral of the sea water. The recovery mode for power shunts to ground is for each PFE to adjust the inserted voltage such that the PFE on each end powers all repeaters between that PFE and the shunt-to-ground fault. In this operating mode, the cable will again continue to operate correctly even with the ground fault somewhere along the cable length. And, as long as the shunt fault is repaired before there is a second fault of either type, the cable will continue to operate without negative customer impact.

Below are cutaway repeaters showing their construction.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

We toured the shore-side storage facilities on our way to the Responder. Left below are customer-owned fiber-optic cables in large metal cylinders used for storage and transport. On the right are large hydraulic cylinders needed at sea for the cable-laying process.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

The Responder’s two captains (two shifts)Daniel Kenealy and Chris Gabrielson, took us through the ship starting with the bridge. Below Capt. Kenealy is explaining each bridge station and their use. Specialized stations for different ship operating modes are located throughout the bridge. When steaming underway, the central bridge stations are used to operate the ship. During docking the ship can be maneuvered by the captain directly via the wing control station at the far left and right side of the bridge. Kenealy explained he prefers instead to get to a location with a better view and gently ease up to the dock via radio commands given to a helmsman.

From the aft end of the bridge, an excellent view can be had of the working deck over which cable is laid, the ROV (remote operated vehicle) is launched and recovered, and the cable-burying sea plow is deployed and recovered.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

This ship is DP2-capable, meaning it can maintain its position with high degrees of precision in rough seas and with redundancy. The dynamic positioning system’s computer will apply thruster or propeller force to hold the boat in an exact GPS-sensed location. This technology is commonly used in the oil exploration business where it is often necessary to keep a boat in an exact position in bad weather and rough seas where any deviation can do substantial damage or even put workers at risk. Because this is a life-critical system and potentially with high-value equipment at risk, it must operate without exception through computer faults or equipment failures.

The DP2 system on the Responder primarily is used to hold position against wind and current in order to place the cable precisely as the ship slowly inches forward laying cable at speeds that can sometimes sink below 1 kt and seldom are far above 3 kts. The dynamic positioning system also is used for remote-operated-vehicle submarine operations and when doing some non-cable related contracts where the ship is near oil rigs or related-equipment.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

A row of cable repeaters is in the first picture below. The subsequent picture is new rope used for raising and lowering cable.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

The first picture below is looking across the three massive cable storage areas in the Responder. If you look carefully, you can see a cable spooling out on the left from the rear storage area and heading out across the two forward in-ship storage areas. The crew was in the process of delivering some cable moved from their Bermuda storage facility to the Baltimore depot.  The second picture is looking down into the rearmost of the three cable storage areas on the boat. The cable being offloaded is visible at the top of the photo, feeding up from the bottom of the storage area where it is neatly spiraled (click any photo for a larger view).

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

Below are pictures of the remote operated vehicle (ROV) used on the Responder and the control center where operators pilot the ROV. This vehicle is used to inspect cable lay positions, move cables to safer locations, and for non-cable related contracts. Sealing the electronics used in the ROV against the seawater outside is a real challenge. This system runs the electronics in an oil bath sealed against seawater intrusion.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view
Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

When cables need to be branched or any repair needing splicing, the cable may need to be cut, captured and lifted onto deck for service using a cutting grapnel.

Click image for a larger view

The following two pictures are of the massive EB Sea Stallion sea plow that is dragged behind the ship when burying cable. This beast can bury cable up to 3 meters by dragging a plow section that cuts through the sea bottom as it pulls forward and the cable is fed in through the blade to the bottom of the trench. The sea plow needs to be precisely controlled and dragged at just the right speed to allow complete burial depending upon sea bottom topography. Considerable skill is required to maintain just the right tension on the plow and the communications cable feeding into it.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

The control room for the EB Sea Stallion sea plow is in a shipping container mounted on deck. The plow is visible towards the stern of the ship on the left of the second picture below.

Click image for a larger view Click image for a larger view

The next three photos show the cable management gear towards the stern of the ship, aft of the three cable storage areas. The cable itself is fed out through a row of rubber tires that grab the cable through friction. Each of these rubber tires is powered by a large electric motor that allows the cable to feed out smoothly at exactly the speed needed without putting the cable under excess load, creating heat through friction, or putting unnecessary mechanical forces that could damage the cable.

Click image for a larger view
Click image for a larger view

Before getting into the details, most industries look far simpler than they really are. In this case, how complex can it be to run a fiber optic cable across a body of water? But the deeper you dig, the more the challenges mount.

When running undersea cables, the ends are almost always in different countries, each having their own permitting process and regulations. Cables need to be as light and inexpensive as possible but, when not protected by extreme depths, they need to armored against damage from anchoring, trawling, and sever weather events. When near shore, cables need to be buried in the sea bottom as deep as 3m to further minimize the damage risk.

Signal integrity can only be maintained by repeaters every 60 to 80 km. These repeaters need to be electrically powered and they need to continue to operate through both power failures and cable insulator faults. Repeaters need to operate reliably for 20+ years even when operating more than 3 miles below the sea surface. Cables need to be spliced together without signal loss while maintaining both mechanical strength and resistance to water intrusion.

TE SubCom controls all the technology from the cable design and manufacture, the repeater design, all the way through to the cable laying and service ships, allowing TE Connectivity to deliver multi-decade solutions both efficiently and economically.

Click image for a larger view

Thanks to the captains and crew of the CS Responder for their hospitality and patience with all of our questions and Mike Rieger, Dave Robles, and Jim Herron of the shore-side team at TE SubCom.


If your comment doesn't show up right away, send us email and we'll dredge it out of the spam filter.

12 comments on “On Board the CS Responder
  1. Peter Chylewski says:

    Thanks for taking me aboard! It was very interesting! I wonder what the impact of the plough on marine life is.

    • The plow cuts a channel big enough to bury the cable and the sled is only a couple of meters wide and the channel is about a 1/4 of that. Compared to some very common forms of fishing, low environmental impact.

    • James Abfalter says:

      having worked on these vessels I can tell you that there are always ocean bottom studies done before any cable laying starts. Most of the bottom is sand or smaller rocks where a plow is used. It digs a deep trench which fills in very quickly after the plow has moved on and only disturbs a very small area. Worked on these ships for over five years and never saw any bottom (there are cameras attached to the plow) that had any real growth because of the lack of light at that depth

  2. Evan Linwood says:

    Fantastic read, I had no idea about the plough or power setup, very surprising to see DC based!
    The Tei Park Communications Museum (Tokyo) had a fair amount of cable related artefacts on display (the only place I’ve seen these items first hand). Sad to see it’s closed now.

  3. Gary says:

    Thank you David and James. Both very good articles for refreshing my knowledge of these things. A visit to the Dirona site always surprises and educates.

  4. Jacques Vuye says:

    I have only one word: Amazing!
    Thank you for once again for sharing another very interesting trip of discovery!
    Have they mentioned the bandwidth of such a cable?

    • The fiber counts wil rise over time but where the biggest bandwidth gains are found is in running more waves per fiber. The growing number of waves (lambdas) per fiber is driven by rapidly improving Dense Wave Division Multiplexing (DWDM) gear. You would think that just including more fibers in a cable is easy and, you are right it is easy. Each fiber is hair thin and certainly more could be accomodated. The limiting factor here are the repeaters.

      Currenty the largest fibers are running 8 pairs, where each pair carries 100 waves to 100GB. That has each pair with a capacity of 10TB and the fully configured cable maxing out at 80TB bidirectional.

      In thinking about your question more, I suspect that repeaters for larger than 8 pairs could be built so I speculate that the real limiting factor is operator demand. Cables represent a single point of potential failure so most operators have mulitple links. If each link can carry up to 80TB, there may not currently be demand to much higher pair count at this point in time. And, as DWDM gear improves, the push for more pairs is dampened by the already massive capacity available using 8 pairs. Given the state of the art in DWDM is currently well beyound 100 lambdas in terestrial applications, I suspect that raising capacity through higher lambda counts is much cheaper than adding more fibers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.