Goodbye GoDaddy

Back in 2005, I maintained a blog accessible only inside of Microsoft where I worked at the time. Having the blog internal to the company allowed confidential topics to be discussed openly, but over time, I found much of what I was writing about might be useful externally. And I knew, if I wanted to have a broader dialog on some topics it would simply have to be external. So, in 2007 I moved the Perspectives blog  external. I already had a boating web site at mvdirona.com hosted with GoDaddy since 2002, so I put the perspectives.mvdirona.com blog there.

Screenshot of perspectives.mvdirona.com on Nov 26, 2007.

perspectives.mvdirona.com Nov 26, 2007

 

The choice of GoDaddy as a hoster is hard to explain these days but, back in 2002 cloud computing didn’t exist, few options were available, and GoDaddy was a only a five-year old and still somewhat nimble start-up. They may have never been great from a customer service perspective but they did offer good value. And, in the end, as long as the site was up I didn’t really need or even want customer service. That choice worked fine for many years. Looking at the rest of technology stack, I chose Das Blog as the blog software, a common option at that time. I chose to use an all Windows stack since I worked at Microsoft and I really ought to use what our customers were using. We also started a boat blog at the same time at blog.mvdirona.com.

mvdirona.com March 11, 2003

 

The last 5 years with GoDaddy have been tough. About once a year, some administrative error or unannounced administrative action takes down the web site. I know that 100% uptime is truly difficult to achieve and I don’t expect 5 nines (99.999%) of availability. 3 nines would be fine and, hey I’m not unreasonable, if they could hit 99.5% availability and not make me spend my entire life on the phone with support, I might even have been able to live with it. Sadly, last year was a 1 nine performance. For someone whose entire focus at work is large system scalability, cost, and availability, it’s somewhere between depressing and embarrassing to not be able to get even close to 99% availability.

But, in many ways, it was a good experience in trying to find time to move the blog in that it closely parallels the decisions enterprise customers have to make when deciding what to do with older workloads and when they should be moved to a new platform. You might think that whenever there is a better choice available where the service is better or the cost is lower, customers would just jump on it. But the truth is, we are all super busy and unless the pain is catastrophically high or the economic gain material, the app stays where it is and we just have to endure the pain. That’s why it is super important to choose the right technology and the right technology partner when you do make a decision with a new application. No matter what you think going in and even if things go badly almost from the start, invariably the relationship ends up being a long lasting one. Moving costs money and time. Companies have businesses to run and re-platforming applications isn’t the top priority for customers or shareholders. On a much smaller scale, the same is true of me. I’ve got a life to lead and, as much as I would like to be on the latest technology stack, I’ve got a full time job and other commitments that keep me fairly busy.

This decision that I knew I had to make just hung around for nearly 5 years. During that period, I knew I absolutely had to migrate the site but more pressing commitments always won. Moving forward to a couple of weeks ago, it’s 2015, and I have a blog still running on Das Blog which is getting to be a pretty tired old choice. I could move to WordPress but I’m running on Windows and I really would prefer to be on Linux for the superior cost structures, higher reliability, and the productivity of the administrative environment. But moving from Windows to Linux is a lot of work in dealing with all the file path separator issues, file system case sensitivity problems, and the large number of differences between IIS and Apache. I could have made all these changes and stayed with GoDaddy. But fresh off another unnecessary and lengthy outage, I was now ready for whatever work is required to migrate the site.

Looking past the poor operational record at GoDaddy, the economics aren’t looking as good as they used to either. When an administrative action or inaction takes down the site, there is no way anything will ever happen unless they are called repeatedly and near constantly. At times, I have even resorted to cheating and directly contacting members of the GoDaddy leadership team that I happen to know. It’s tiresome, I hate having the site down, the personal time cost is annoying and, making it worse, the 7 day outage in 2013 happened while we were at sea in a small boat between the Society Islands and Tonga, and all the calls back to GoDaddy were via an expensive satellite phone link. Considering all the costs and poor operational results, it was clearly time for a move.

The transition is now done, I hope you like it, and wow, what a relief. I know there will be downtime again in the future but I’m almost looking forward to it at this point. Just being able to log in and make whatever change is needed rather than calling support and trying to convince someone that it really isn’t working, no I didn’t change anything, no I don’t want to upgrade to the new premium service, yes I’ll hold on the line, thanks I do know my call is important, no I really haven’t changed anything, no it’s not the case that it’s coding error on the site, …. There is quite possibly nothing worse that talking to someone who will talk to someone else for you who will eventually open a trouble ticket that will only be looked at a couple of days from now by an over-worked system administrator. I’m sure the administrator that eventually reads the trouble ticket will do their level best but for lack of context, insufficient detail in the ticket, and possibly lack of time, they probably will miss the mark on the first interaction. When 72 hour turnaround on site outage events is policy, the process is slow and very frustrating. Ironically each failed interaction with the site still down yields a fresh request for a customer service survey response.

It was a ton of work to move from Das Blog to WordPress, from ASP to PHP, from Windows to Linux, from Goddady DNS to Route53, and from GoDaddy hosting to Amazon Web Services but it is wonderful to have it done. I just love that it’s all open source and that it all can be changed, reconfigured, and there are thousands of experts running the same software all around the world and many are happy to help.

It’s great to finally step into this century and, for all those out there trying to figure out when it is the right time to move to cloud computing, get going! It’s so nice not to be “owned” by your provider and to have control back in your hands. It’s wonderful to be on new technology where new features are coming out every week, where there is a healthy ecosystem of companies adding services on top, and where there are experts all over the world. What a relief to be in control and be able to make changes or get issues corrected quickly. Here’s to at least 2 1/2 nines!

Committing the last change that severs the links to GoDaddy.

Committing the last change that severs the links to GoDaddy


If your comment doesn't show up right away, send us email and we'll dredge it out of the spam filter.


8 comments on “Goodbye GoDaddy
  1. David Andrews says:

    I have followed your travels, intermittently, for a while and have just subscribed. My principal reason is to let you know how much easier it now is to follow your travels on my tablet – an Asus Transformer. Previously it could be something of a trial; now it is a nice experience.

    Enoy the Grand Prix – you seem very adept at picking your route and destinations.

    • David, thanks for letting know the new format is working better on your mobile device. Getting mobile right or closer to right was one of our goals. I’m glad it’s working better from your perspective.

      You are right, we have been lucky on our location timing and attending the F1 race is a very cool opportunity. The pit walk through to get up close to the teams preparing the cars for the first race weekend is tomorrow morning at 9am. We’re looking forward to it.

  2. John Worl says:

    Lookin’ good James! Glad you are up and running. Will miss you and Jennifer at the Crab Feed tonight.

    • It’s great hearing from you John. Today we are anchored at Deal Island, Tasmania expecting a bit of weather today and then settled conditions for the few days after that. We plan to explore the island and then cross Bass Straight on route to Melbourne for the Formula 1 race. We’re glad to hear the Bellvue Power and Sail Squadron Crab Feed tradition lives on. Have a great time and please pass on our greatings to the group.

  3. Jacques Vuye says:

    Well, there you have it!
    From a reader perspective, the conversion looks seamless.
    Having been retired from the IT business for over 15 years now, I can see how much ground has been covered since!
    BTW, my current desktop “hardware” ((-: (Tablet + Bluetooth KB) looks exactly like yours…so I am not **totally** outpaced.
    Maybe “older” person, but feels good not to be “outdated”
    Glad also to get a little perspective on what AA really means when dealing with Microsoft….(-;

    • James Hamilton says:

      Good hearing from you Jacques. Let us know if you see any issues on the web site but, at this point, I think everything is operating as it should. The long tail of missing links caused by Windows being case insensitive while Linux is case sensitive seem to be largely solved.

  4. Chasm says:

    Ah, the joy of software migration. (The only joy is that you don’t have to work with the old software any longer. Hopefully the new software is better.)

    Looks like a smooth transition from my perspective.
    Forwarding the rss link worked, time to change the feed. Skipping through the old feed, the content does not fall apart. (pictures, etc.) Comments made the transition. Looks good to me.

    I did not have AWS on the radar for small projects, interesting.
    To more uptime. =)

    • James Hamilton says:

      Chasm nailed it when he said the only joy of softare migration is you don’t have to work with the old software any longer. You’re right it’s always more work than expected and this one was no exception. We still need to get backups going and ensure that the site can recover from failure so a bit more work ahead. Thanks for the confirming it’s working well on your end. Nice to hear.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *